Sampler Or Usb Controller, Which one is better for Mac users? Options

[MacDJ07]

Ok....I'm just getting into making my own hip hop and dance beats and I'm not really sure if what I'm going to ask is understandable, so feel free to ask me for more information if you need to.

I have been looking around for a beat machine basically, and I've come across a couple of different kinds of hardware that seem to do the same stuff. I was looking at the Rowland SP-404 and that is a (sampler). Then I have also been looking on the Akai midi pad controller (http://www.zzounds.com/item--AKAMPD32) and it seems that this product can also make beats and it has pads just like the SP-404. I understand that the MPD32 is strictly usb, but from my understanding the SP-404 can also be hooked up to the computer.

Would it be better to use the USB Controller (Akai MPD32) or the Sampler (Rowland SP-404) on my Mac? And what is the difference other than the connection?

I have a MacBook with OS X and just mess around with Garageband right now but can get Logic if I need to.

Thanx for your time and responses.....

[houstonmusic]

Hi,
i believe you're right, those devices are basically similar, built in samples not withstanding. If pads are what you want, the physical feel and vibe is crucial. You've got to get to your local music store and try them out.

I program my beats in two basically different ways, either from a keyboard, triggering samples in DP (plug in samplers) or Reason, or in a graphic/visual way in a grid window or step sequencer.

both have their benefits. I know people who would never program with pads or keys, and some who would rather die than have a step sequencer control their feel.

for what it's worth, the young beat makers i know best are using Reason, and each has found their own particular and sometimes peculiar way to work. I like Reason very much too. it's samplers and beat machines allow for great flexibility and power, and it integrates with GarageBand via ReWire, so linear audio tracks aren't a problem. i'd look at Reason before Logic.

happy hunting

This post has been edited by houstonmusic: Tue 3 Jun 2008, 16:35

[mortalengines]

I think it just depends on what you want to do with it. The 404 is a sampler and not necessarily a controller. If you want to trigger drum sounds (and maybe some others) in your computer and then maybe manipulate other parameters in your software (like controlling a filter or delay times and whatnot) then the MPD is probably going to be the one for you. It looks pretty cool but, the MPD 24 is kind of expensive....Akai also makes some less expensive controllers as well that you may want to consider if you want to go a little less "cadillac". M-audio also makes the Trigger Finger which is like the Akai but less expensive.


www.myspace.com/mortal_engines