Cubase Vs. Digital Performer., Vs. |
Thu 11 Mar 2004, 20:20
Post
#1
|
|
Newbie Group: Members Posts: 11 Joined: 11-Mar 04 From: Cairo - EG Member No.: 38,251 |
I am just confused which software is best for Midi,i am working with pro-tools digi002 for audio but i need a good Midi sequencer and i am stuck in between cubase and digital performer..Any hints??
|
|
|
Replies
Tue 16 Mar 2004, 19:36
Post
#2
|
|
Rookie Group: Members Posts: 28 Joined: 02-Feb 04 From: Nashville - US Member No.: 34,758 |
Let's get specific. DP does not have individual undo of quantizing. That's a big ommision. Say you record a drum part via midi, then you quantize the whole thing. Then suppose you play it back and it's OK everywhere except in one place in the middle of the song. You cannot undo the quantizing in that area without also undoing every other note after that point in the song. Even Cubase VST32 can unquantize a single note- even days later after you've made dozens of other edits. You can always return to the unquantized state. That's pretty cool. However, Steinberg who makes Cubase has the worst tech support of any product I've ever purchased. Whoever said that their forums were filled with angry users was right. That should way heavily in a vote, I would think.
Logic which has loyal followers is known to be hard to learn. It has been purchased by Apple who may simplify it, but they currently offer no crossgrade and upped the price to almost $1000. I'm also hearing from my dealer that Apple is not providing them with the training and info that Logic did in the past. In my opinion, there is not a Mac sequencer currently available that is stable, has good tech support, is user friendly, and has the features I need. But you're probably someone like me that just loves sampling and midi and sees it as the future of music and so you have to choose SOMETHING. Tough choice. Let's hope these forums are a wake-up call to manufacturers who are not really offering us very good options. |
|
|
Posts in this topic
The_Circle Cubase Vs. Digital Performer. Thu 11 Mar 2004, 20:20
surrealka I'm not very familiar with cubase, so I can... Sat 13 Mar 2004, 20:10
The_Circle I think it's a bit hard to compare between the... Sat 13 Mar 2004, 20:26
jetcity Hey there. I use DP 4.12 and love it. It's v... Sat 13 Mar 2004, 21:13
The_Circle Well i guess i should consider dp and give it a tr... Sat 13 Mar 2004, 22:17
sethjacquay Back the snack up boys! Anyone, who says DP 4 ... Mon 15 Mar 2004, 17:59
td3k QUOTE (The_Circle @ Mar 11 2004, 14:20)... Mon 15 Mar 2004, 19:56
sethjacquay td3k, Just out of curiosity, why do you feel Cuba... Mon 15 Mar 2004, 21:00
rickenbacker Steinberg promise a lot of things for Cubase on th... Tue 16 Mar 2004, 12:17
sethjacquay Rickenbacker, Can you confirm the support of VST ... Tue 16 Mar 2004, 16:45
rickenbacker Apple have not simplified Logic with Logic 6 Pro/E... Wed 17 Mar 2004, 13:21
sethjacquay The Circle, My last post on this topic. I don... Wed 17 Mar 2004, 16:09
The_Circle Well i totally agree that picking one of the 3 is ... Wed 17 Mar 2004, 19:56
editbrain geez! if you want a product that works and is... Wed 17 Mar 2004, 20:51
surrealka Two responses: First to The Circle: the VST-AU wr... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 01:52
The_Circle Well thanks editbrain, i think i shall consider ge... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 13:38
pdgood Do any of you Logic users know if it has the indiv... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 14:27
sethjacquay Well...they are "on crack" aren't th... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 14:34
surrealka He he! Fri 19 Mar 2004, 22:14
gdoubleyou Steinberg has good ideas but fall short on executi... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 22:43
editbrain my goodness....i did not know that cubase was pinn... Sat 20 Mar 2004, 01:29
The_Circle surrealka,Maybe Logic is a bit harder to get along... Sat 20 Mar 2004, 17:27
surrealka You're absolutely right, and I hope I haven... Sun 21 Mar 2004, 21:12
Panopticon Well, count me as another crack abuser who finds D... Wed 24 Mar 2004, 09:54
rickenbacker I'd say the Logic Pro package offers over and ... Wed 24 Mar 2004, 16:28
The_Circle Hehe..it seems that most of whoever is in this for... Wed 24 Mar 2004, 21:08
gdoubleyou Maybe I have more experience but I didn't find... Thu 25 Mar 2004, 01:53
pdgood No one is taking the $$$ into accou... Thu 25 Mar 2004, 19:46
surrealka pdgood, yes DP has MIDI scrub. And good AU integra... Fri 26 Mar 2004, 00:22
gdoubleyou SX2 just had an update released, check Cubase.net ... Fri 26 Mar 2004, 01:00
newrigel If your a proficient performer (keyboadist) you re... Sat 27 Mar 2004, 18:44
surrealka I found this good article comparing different sequ... Sat 27 Mar 2004, 20:39
newrigel QUOTE (gdoubleyou @ Mar 26 2004, 00:00) SX2 ... Tue 30 Mar 2004, 21:36
surrealka I'm not very familiar with cubase, so I can... Sat 13 Mar 2004, 20:10
The_Circle I think it's a bit hard to compare between the... Sat 13 Mar 2004, 20:26
jetcity Hey there. I use DP 4.12 and love it. It's v... Sat 13 Mar 2004, 21:13
The_Circle Well i guess i should consider dp and give it a tr... Sat 13 Mar 2004, 22:17
sethjacquay Back the snack up boys! Anyone, who says DP 4 ... Mon 15 Mar 2004, 17:59
td3k QUOTE (The_Circle @ Mar 11 2004, 14:20)... Mon 15 Mar 2004, 19:56
sethjacquay td3k, Just out of curiosity, why do you feel Cuba... Mon 15 Mar 2004, 21:00
rickenbacker Steinberg promise a lot of things for Cubase on th... Tue 16 Mar 2004, 12:17
sethjacquay Rickenbacker, Can you confirm the support of VST ... Tue 16 Mar 2004, 16:45
rickenbacker Apple have not simplified Logic with Logic 6 Pro/E... Wed 17 Mar 2004, 13:21
sethjacquay The Circle, My last post on this topic. I don... Wed 17 Mar 2004, 16:09
The_Circle Well i totally agree that picking one of the 3 is ... Wed 17 Mar 2004, 19:56
editbrain geez! if you want a product that works and is... Wed 17 Mar 2004, 20:51
surrealka Two responses: First to The Circle: the VST-AU wr... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 01:52
The_Circle Well thanks editbrain, i think i shall consider ge... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 13:38
pdgood Do any of you Logic users know if it has the indiv... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 14:27
sethjacquay Well...they are "on crack" aren't th... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 14:34
surrealka He he! Fri 19 Mar 2004, 22:14
gdoubleyou Steinberg has good ideas but fall short on executi... Fri 19 Mar 2004, 22:43
editbrain my goodness....i did not know that cubase was pinn... Sat 20 Mar 2004, 01:29
The_Circle surrealka,Maybe Logic is a bit harder to get along... Sat 20 Mar 2004, 17:27
surrealka You're absolutely right, and I hope I haven... Sun 21 Mar 2004, 21:12
Panopticon Well, count me as another crack abuser who finds D... Wed 24 Mar 2004, 09:54
rickenbacker I'd say the Logic Pro package offers over and ... Wed 24 Mar 2004, 16:28
The_Circle Hehe..it seems that most of whoever is in this for... Wed 24 Mar 2004, 21:08
gdoubleyou Maybe I have more experience but I didn't find... Thu 25 Mar 2004, 01:53
pdgood No one is taking the $$$ into accou... Thu 25 Mar 2004, 19:46
surrealka pdgood, yes DP has MIDI scrub. And good AU integra... Fri 26 Mar 2004, 00:22
gdoubleyou SX2 just had an update released, check Cubase.net ... Fri 26 Mar 2004, 01:00
newrigel If your a proficient performer (keyboadist) you re... Sat 27 Mar 2004, 18:44
surrealka I found this good article comparing different sequ... Sat 27 Mar 2004, 20:39
newrigel QUOTE (gdoubleyou @ Mar 26 2004, 00:00) SX2 ... Tue 30 Mar 2004, 21:36
9 User(s) are reading this topic (9 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members: