MacMusic.org  |  PcMusic.org  |  440Software  |  440Forums.com  |  440Tv  |  Zicos.com  |  AudioLexic.org
Loading... visitors connected
Welcome Guest
> Multi-track Recording Software, Software that is simple and works in OSX
Dadoo
post Mon 12 Jan 2004, 05:21
Post #1


Member
**

Group: Members
Posts: 50
Joined: 04-Jan 04
From: Oliver - CA
Member No.: 32,387




I'm just getting into the fascinating world of digital music recording. My wife and I play music together for small and large group things. I would like to be able to add some fullness to our sound by creating our own accompaniment CD's so that we can play along with a "full band", so to speak.

I just got the M-Audio Audiophile USB and it came with a "lite" version of Ableton DELTA Live. I've played around with it some and have recorded a couple of things. I find it rather complicated for what I'm doing, as I think it is more of a looping/sequencing instrument that just happens to have recording capabilities. I also find it frustrating to get sound consistently in and out of the program as I seem to have to quit and restart the program for it to recognize that I have an audio input for it. But this may be beside the point because I think it is not the right program for what I want to do.

I have hear a little about a shareware program for OS X called Jasmine. I see that I can download a demo of it. Does anyone have any experience with this program? Basically what I want to do is to plug in my bass, guitar, keyboard, drum machine, maybe some backing vocals, and record them on different tracks and then make them into an AIFF file that can be burned onto a CD. I want it to be simple and able to produce good digital quality sound. Will Jasmine work for me? Is there another simple and basic program that works in OS X that I should look at?

I'm doing my recording on a 600 MHz iMac, running OS 10.2.8, with 512 MB of RAM.

Thanks for your replies. I know I have much to learn!
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post
 
Start new topic
Replies
braj
post Sun 8 Feb 2004, 01:25
Post #2


Newbie


Group: Members
Posts: 23
Joined: 08-Jan 04
From: San Francisco - US
Member No.: 32,729




QUOTE (Dadoo @ Feb 7 2004, 23:17)
In my other Topic, which is actually a poll, Metro 6 SE is ahead so far in votes. Is it really that good? To me it seems to have quite a few features, but looks quite cumbersome to use and is for OS 9 and OS X, and some features work in one and not the other. Tracktion looks easier to use and is made only for OS X. Intuem 2.1 looks easy to use, like Tractkion, seems to have a good interface, and also is able to convert MIDI tracks to audio (which I don't think Metro or Tracktion can do).

Metro is powerful, but cumbersome, and the SE version is intentionally crippled with limitations (only one software synth besides Soundfonts -or- 3 effects). Traction doesn't have this limitation and is way easier to use.

Intuem has terrible support. I was considering it, but they never responded to several e-mails and there is no user community.

Tracktion has a good community with forums hosted at here. Really, this would be your best choice. The code base is multiplatform, newer than Metro, and the recent relationship with Mackie means it is growing into a real pro app. $80 for the full version compared to $69 for Metro SE's crippleware, or $80 for Intuem's lack of support and deep featureset. Really, there is no reasonable comparison. Tracktion is the best value.

Tracktion can convert Midi to audio (freeze to use later as midi or render to audio). It is much more flexible than Intuem by comparison, which only converts to audio.

I would say this: a lot of Mac users are more familiar with Metro since it has been on the Mac for a long time, so it's no surprise it won in your poll. If I hadn't discovered Tracktion, I would likely agree. What Metro SE is really good for is a GM sequencer, to open .mid files and remix them, or to create tracks specifically for later use in another sequencer or for distributing on the web to be played by Quicktime. There is plenty to like, but if you want to do more than just use GM sounds, it starts to get too complicated for efficient use, IMO. Since it isn't widely used in pro situations, I don't think it is worth investing the time to 'figure out'. IO spent plenty of time on the Metro forums and help files trying to figure out things that are easy as can be in Tracktion.
Go to the top of the page
 
+Quote Post

Posts in this topic
- Dadoo   Multi-track Recording Software   Mon 12 Jan 2004, 05:21
- - kaboombahchuck   I'm thinking Metro SE will work best for your...   Mon 12 Jan 2004, 05:32
- - swilder   Audacity is a hip little app if you don't need...   Mon 12 Jan 2004, 07:28
- - Dadoo   Thanks for the tips so far. I have never heard of ...   Tue 13 Jan 2004, 02:13
- - TYDYMKR   I USE AUDACITY FOR RECORDING AND SPARK LE FOR EDIT...   Tue 13 Jan 2004, 07:38
- - swilder   I haven't tried out the demo yet but this look...   Tue 13 Jan 2004, 19:11
- - rickenbacker   Intuem really sucked when I tried it last year. Ma...   Wed 14 Jan 2004, 15:26
- - Dadoo   I'm really appreciating all the tips. It's...   Thu 15 Jan 2004, 02:37
- - Dadoo   Now, I know this program is OS 9 only, but what ab...   Thu 15 Jan 2004, 06:40
- - kaboombahchuck   I started out with cubase, and got no where.. the ...   Thu 15 Jan 2004, 08:08
- - rickenbacker   If your Mac can boot into OS 9, Cubasis is OK. Fin...   Thu 15 Jan 2004, 13:27
- - Dadoo   I've looked at some of the other Steinberg sof...   Fri 16 Jan 2004, 02:50
- - rickenbacker   Try the demo of Tracktion, too.   Fri 16 Jan 2004, 16:49
- - swilder   I tried Jasmine once. I really didn't care for...   Fri 16 Jan 2004, 18:47
- - swilder   QUOTE (Dadoo @ Jan 16 2004, 01:50)From that I...   Fri 16 Jan 2004, 18:51
- - Dadoo   Thanks again all who have given their input into t...   Sat 17 Jan 2004, 01:57
- - Dadoo   Funny thing about Tracktion. I found the website a...   Sat 17 Jan 2004, 19:58
- - Sonne   hi You should check out ProTools   Sun 18 Jan 2004, 14:09
- - jpschmader   QUOTE (Dadoo @ Jan 17 2004, 18:58)Funny thing...   Sun 18 Jan 2004, 18:24
- - Dadoo   Thanks for the link to the Tracktion website. I gu...   Sun 18 Jan 2004, 23:53
- - Dadoo   Okay. A quick poll for anyone interested in offeri...   Sun 25 Jan 2004, 02:55
- - jpschmader   tracktion   Sun 25 Jan 2004, 03:48
- - thompsot   If you will never need MIDI, then audacity would b...   Sun 25 Jan 2004, 06:54
- - Dadoo   Any other votes? Thanks!   Tue 27 Jan 2004, 00:57
- - Siddy   Another suggestion, here in England there is a kit...   Tue 27 Jan 2004, 13:49
- - RGirardi   regarding the Logic Hit Kit... Could you point me ...   Thu 29 Jan 2004, 20:42
- - Siddy   Hi - I got the name slightly wrong - it is "T...   Thu 29 Jan 2004, 20:55
- - Dadoo   Thanks for the advice about the Hit Kit. Any other...   Fri 30 Jan 2004, 02:02
- - braj   I just ordered the Hit Kit from Barnes and Knoble ...   Fri 30 Jan 2004, 07:27
- - Dadoo   There does not seem to be too many more replies to...   Mon 2 Feb 2004, 00:55
- - braj   I got the Hit Kit and I have to say I was disappoi...   Thu 5 Feb 2004, 00:16
- - Dadoo   Hey braj. Thanks for the tip re: the Hit Kit. It d...   Thu 5 Feb 2004, 00:47
- - braj   I actually own Metro and have to say it is powerfu...   Thu 5 Feb 2004, 04:21
- - Dadoo   With my setup (G3 iMac 600 MHz, 512 MB RAM, OS 10....   Fri 6 Feb 2004, 06:37
- - Dadoo   If you are reading this topic, then please check o...   Sat 7 Feb 2004, 21:20
- - braj   Of the four in your poll, Tracktion is definitely ...   Sat 7 Feb 2004, 22:33
- - braj   And Tracktion should run very well on your G3. You...   Sat 7 Feb 2004, 22:37
- - Dadoo   Wow! Thanks braj. Sounds good to me. I appreci...   Sat 7 Feb 2004, 23:07
- - Dadoo   In my other Topic, which is actually a poll, Metro...   Sun 8 Feb 2004, 00:17
- - braj   Tracktion also has Rewire support, which allows me...   Sun 8 Feb 2004, 01:28
- - Dadoo   QUOTE (braj @ Feb 8 2004, 00:28)Tracktion als...   Sun 8 Feb 2004, 02:21
- - braj   QUOTE (Dadoo @ Feb 8 2004, 01:21)QUOTE (braj ...   Sun 8 Feb 2004, 02:28
- - Dadoo   Thanks for the explanation braj, although I will a...   Sun 8 Feb 2004, 03:44
- - Dadoo   Hi again braj. I contacted the Tracktion guys abou...   Wed 11 Feb 2004, 01:13
- - braj   The beautiful thing about Tracktion is that you ca...   Wed 11 Feb 2004, 01:23
- - Dadoo   Excellent braj. Your comments are very helpful. Th...   Wed 11 Feb 2004, 02:18
- - Dadoo   I posted this message in my "poll" but t...   Sun 18 Apr 2004, 20:40


Reply to this topicStart new topic
2 User(s) are reading this topic (2 Guests and 0 Anonymous Users)
0 Members:

 

Lo-Fi Version - Sun 24 Nov 2024, 14:55
- © MacMusic 1997-2008