Printable Version of Topic

Click here to view this topic in its original format

440 Forums _ Getting Started _ Best Notation/midi Sequencer/audio Editing

Posted by: lamplighter Mon 18 Apr 2005, 03:04

In case this question is asked frequently, my apologies in advance.
I'm on an eMac G4 with 1 GB memory.

Currently researching and seeking info on a combination notation program with MIDI sequencing and audio editing capabilities - such as the ability to combine digital audio and MIDI. I'm basically familiar with the Finale family but would like more info on available options. I understand that ProTools is for film scoring and would like to know more about Logic - any suggestions and info welcome.

Thanks for your time!

Posted by: Adrian Delso Mon 18 Apr 2005, 09:49

Here is what Dr Andrea Pejrolo says in his overview of four leading software sequencers, from his excellent "Creative Sequencing Techniques for Music Production", Focal Press, 2005:

ProTools 6.2.2 (Digidesign) Very reliable; solid audio editor; solid mixing features; easy learning curve; Mac and PC, BUT basic MIDI features and supports Digidesign interfaces only.

Logic Pro 6.4.2 (Apple, was Emagic) Most advanced editing; advanced score editor; stable; customisable, works with loads of interfaces, BUT steep learning curve (he ain't kidding!), unconventional terminology and shortcuts; time-consuming to configure; Mac only;

Cubase SX 2.2 (Steinberg) Intuitive interface; advanced score editor; advanced MIDI; Mac and PC; BUT could be more stable; audio editing could be improved (I think he means plug-ins aren't as good as e.g. Logic)

Digital Performer 4.12 (Mark of the Unicorn) Clear graphic interface; great MIDI features; fairly easy learning curve; "musical" approach; BUT score editor needs improvement; track list window limited; could be more stable; needs a powerful computer for a high number of tracks; Mac only.

From what you say about your needs, I would suggest either Cubase or Logic, depending on your computer. You may find that the Cubase LE and Logic Express versions are adequate and will be about one-third the price!

Hope this helps,

Adrian

Posted by: kaboombahchuck Mon 18 Apr 2005, 14:22

I like http://nav.440network.com/out.php?mmsc=forums&url=http://www.sagantech.biz/products.htm . Pretty good bang for the buck. They do have a free demo download available, and a dedicated forum for support. I have had no problems running external hardware (althogh I am partial to the MOTU line of products.)